SACCO dividends vs fixed deposits: Which is a better investment?

For many Kenyans, choosing the best way to grow their money is a key financial decision. Two popular avenues for saving and earning returns are SACCOs (Savings and Credit Cooperative Societies) and bank fixed deposits (FDs). Both offer ways to earn from your money, but they differ in risk, returns, liquidity, and accessibility. Understanding how SACCO dividends and fixed deposit interest work is essential to make smart financial choices.

What Are SACCO Dividends?

SACCOs are member-owned cooperatives where members pool savings to provide loans and other financial services.

• Dividends are the profits distributed to members at the end of the financial year.
• The dividend depends on the SACCO’s annual performance, including loan repayments, investments, and operational costs.
• Dividends are not guaranteed; a SACCO may perform well and pay high dividends, or face losses and pay little to none.
• SACCO dividends are often tax-free, increasing their appeal compared to taxable bank interest.

Example: A SACCO may declare an annual dividend of 12-15% on members’ shares based on the year’s performance.

What Are Bank Fixed Deposits?

Fixed deposits are savings accounts where money is kept for a fixed period, typically ranging from 1 month to 5 years, at a predetermined interest rate.

• Banks guarantee the interest, which is fixed and paid at maturity or periodically.
• Fixed deposit rates are usually lower than SACCO dividends, but they are predictable and secure.
• They are suitable for risk-averse savers who prioritize safety over high returns.
• Interest earned is taxable, which reduces net gains.

Example: A 12-month fixed deposit in Kenya may offer 6% annual interest, payable at the end of the term.

Comparing Returns

1. Potential Earnings
   • SACCO dividends often range from 10% to 20% annually, depending on performance.
   • Bank fixed deposits usually offer 3% to 8%, making them lower in potential returns but more predictable.
2. Risk
   • SACCO dividends are variable and depend on the SACCO’s financial health. Poor loan recovery or mismanagement can reduce returns.
   • Fixed deposits are low-risk, with banks being regulated and deposits often insured by the Deposit Protection Fund.
3. Liquidity
   • SACCO funds may have limited liquidity. Some SACCOs allow members to withdraw shares, but there may be restrictions or notice periods.
   • Fixed deposits lock in funds for the term; early withdrawal usually incurs penalties, reducing the effective interest earned.
4. Tax Treatment
   • SACCO dividends are tax-free, making the effective return higher than the nominal rate.
   • Fixed deposit interest is subject to withholding tax, usually 15%, lowering the net return.
5. Additional Benefits
   • SACCOs often offer access to low-interest loans, emergency funds, and other member benefits.
   • Fixed deposits are purely a savings and investment tool with no additional services.

Which One Should You Choose?

• For higher potential returns and long-term savings, SACCOs are attractive, especially for members who also benefit from low-interest loans and other cooperative services.
• For guaranteed returns and lower risk, fixed deposits are safer, especially if you have short-term goals or need guaranteed access to funds after the term ends.
• Many savers use a combination of both: SACCOs for higher growth and benefits, and fixed deposits for secure, predictable returns.

Author: Andrew Walyaula

Andrew Walyaula is a seasoned multimedia journalist. Email: waliaulaandrew0@gmail.com